Part Two - Lessons from Benny, a Fear Aggressive Mill Dog Rescue
Benny was a Havanese rescue adopted from NMDR by a caretaker named Pat. Pat contacted me in hopes of resolving some of Benny’s behavior issues. In my interview with Pat, I learned that Benny was surrendered at a year old. I knew that was exceptionally young for a mill dog rescue. In our discussion, Pat explained that Benny had lived in the mill dog breeding facility until he was a year old, because unlike most their Havanese puppies none of the pet shops bought him, citing they felt an all-white male Havanese was too hard to sell.
During my initial interview with Benny’s caretaker, I asked about possible health issues with the dog and about the dog’s diet. Pat said there was no significant medical problems cited by the veterinarian except the dog had a more “sensitive tummy, likely due to stress. The vet put him on a special diet to help.
I then queried about what training was done with Benny and learned that Pat, who had a degree in psychology, did the dog’s initial basic training and work to calm the dog. However, she was struggling to resolve Benny’s incessant barking, reluctance to walk on a leash outside of the house, and the not wanting to interact with Pat’s husband or adult son. When Pat encouraged Benny to meet with people coming into the house, he would approach the strangers, but sometimes unexpectedly bit them.
I was not the first trainer Pat consulted. Pat had previously hired a dog trainer to work on Benny’s barking. The trainer showed Pat how to toss a penny can at Benny to stop the barking. Pat’s psychology education left her no doubt that Benny’s fear-based issues were not well addressed with adversity, and after Benny froze then ran in response to the tossed penny can, Pat stopped the training lesson and didn’t have the trainer come back. When Pat contacted me, Benny was still not wanting to walk on a leash outside of the house, and not friendly with her son or husband. But her main concern was when Pat tried to encourage Benny to greet people who came in the house, because he sometimes bit them.
How I Set Up My Arrival for Working With Benny
When I work with dogs who are highly reactive to people coming into the house, I query the dog’s owner extensively to determine what antecedents I need to avoid when entering the home. I talked to Pat about avoiding antecedents such as me knocking on the door or ringing a doorbell, and said I wanted to call her on my cell phone when I arrived and let myself in. She agreed to this. I also requested that the dog be on a leash since she didn’t feel that would trigger leash reactivity, and I asked that Pat stand back from the door with the dog.
My entrance into the house went fairly well, but due to the design of the entry, I was much closer to Benny than I’d have liked after closing the door. I do a lot of desensitization when dealing with fear issues, and distance is a favorite tool and can also be used as an operant tool. Utilizing distance with stressed or fearful dog is also discussed in Rugaas’ book on calming signals. After I closed the door, the picture below shows the look Benny gave me. I turned on my camera to video this encounter.
When Benny first looked at me, he seemed uncertain as to what to do. He was used to moving forward towards people, but he’d too often decide to bite. I’d requested the owner use a leash stop that process. However, I suspected if I made any wrong moves from his perspective, I could trigger a fear response. I stood very still and began to talk with Pat.
I wanted to offer Benny reassurance that I was not a threat. My first attempt was to take a step farther away (adding distance). Unfortunately, that wasn’t received well by Benny. He took a step towards me only to be stopped by Pat. She tried to get him to sit, but he wanted to keep his focus on me, looking a bit more concerned than I’d like. My next effort to calm Benny included standing still, using calm breathing, presenting a soft gaze rather than staring at him, and not attempting to interact with him physically or verbally. I was pleased that Pat also conversed in calm tones during our conversation.
After talking with Pat for a few minutes, I decided to occasionally do calming signals. My goal with the calming signals was a hope that offering this kind of canine communication element would help Benny relax.
During my conversation with Pat, I used two calming signals, a quarter head turn and the yawn that Kelly said worked the best for Hoosier. I didn’t change my posture, tone of voice or indirect gaze with using the head turn calming signal. After I casually turned my head sideways about a quarter of a turn, I held that position for a few moments before returning my head to the forward position. During our discussion, I was glad that Pat didn’t once show anger about situations she talked about or display excitement during the conversation. I’ve noted some dogs who are feeling uncertain tend to tense or show unease when emotions reflect in their caretaker’s voice. During my conversation with Pat, I included a brief explanation about what I was doing with my occasional calming signal.
What to Watch for in the Upcoming Video of My Work Using Calming Signals with Benny
The upcoming video is from my initial meeting with Benny. The camera shows Benny being held by his owner, as I was the one taking the video. What isn’t seen on the video are my calming signals using head turns and yawns.
Please take note when:
Benny broke his stare at me and walked behind his owner. I took that opportunity to back up a step wanting to add a little more distance. Benny tensed from my movement, even though I had moved farther away.
I continued my talking with Pat in calm tones, and offered Benny occasional head turn calming signals. I noted that when Pat guided Benny to sit, that he was too uncertain to sit for very long.
You see me turn the camera to a dog in a nearby pen in the hallway, and if you watch closely, you will see Benny glance towards that dog before I moved my camera. This dog kept barking the entire time, which likely bothered Benny. It certainly bothered me.
After I started to do an occasional yawns, Benny began to approach me. His approach, where he sniffed and came in a bit of an arc, was talked about in the book on calming signals. Turid’s book explained this was an amiable way for a dog to approach when the dog is not wanting conflict.
It isn’t unusual for a small dog to react poorly if you loom over the dog and bend to try to make contact, even if you just want to pet the dog. For that reason, I sat down to get closer to Benny’s level. I noted that Benny didn’t direct his focus at me like he did when I had taken a step backwards. After Benny sniffed my hand, he gave me a brief head turn calming signal. As Benny got closer, Pat reminded me that after Benny had approach other people, then he bit. I responded to that information by not moving my hand at all, even after Benny again sniffed my hand. While keeping my hand still, I offered more calming signals: two consecutive wide-mouth yawns. He looked at me with soft eyes while sniffing the air. I continued to keep my hand still. After Benny rubbed his head against my hand and I returned some rubbing.
Video: Benny Calming Signals Movie
Link to YouTube https://youtu.be/dBYJQJyatIo
Sidebar: My Wide Mouthed Yawn
When I do the wide mouth yawn, I actually feel it relaxes me a little. I take in a slow, deep breaths which I can feel in my belly. At the same time I take in my breath, I open my mouth and moving my gaze upwards. As I slowly turn my head to the side, I close my eyes and begin to exhale. When my head is at the side, I open my eyes and take in another relaxed deep breath after which I calmly return my head forward. I never stare directly in a fearful dogs eyes.
I wish I’d have understood the importance of the arc approach before Otis bit my husband’s hand. Although I’d approached Otis many times before that fateful day he bit my husband, the intensity, and my straight towards the dog approach clearly didn’t work for Otis. Still, I learned from the Otis’ episode to be aware of my approach with fearful dogs, even if they were used to me approaching them, and I learned from Benny to try an arc approach.
I understand from both Turid’s book and from Benny’s actions that sniffing the ground during an approach in an arc has a significance. Since I can’t sniff the ground when approaching with an arc, I substitute looking towards the ground. I’ve had great responses from my first time meeting of a client’s fearful and uncertain dog when using the arced approach. While approaching a dog in an arch and watching the ground, I keep part of my attention on the dog. If the dog tenses, I stop and give a sideways head turn like Benny did with me. My success using this technique with a new clients dog, has brought me comments like “I can’t believe you just walked up to my dog.” and “My dog has never felt this relaxed the first time he met someone new.
My experience with using calming signals with Benny was very unique. I’d used calming signals with Abby, and with Otis. I’d also watch Kelly during the photo shoot illustrate several ways she used different calming signals with Hoosier. When I used calming signals with Benny, along with my other desensitization techniques, this was the first time I had a dog use calming signals to communicate back to me. Even having read Turid’s book and seen Kelley’s illustrations which included Hoosier yawning back to Kelly, I can only wish I knew what all Benny was trying to communicate to me with his signals. I also wondered how well he understood my efforts to communicate to him with my head turns and yawns. None the less, it appeared that the calming signals I used helped to relax Benny. I also noted he seemed more cooperative then other dogs when I worked that day to begin his reform training. He also showed more trust than I’d have expected considering how he looked at me when he first saw me and I wonder if our calming signals exchange helped that as well.
Using Calming Signals with a Fearful Rescue
Mowgli (Mow) and Chloe
Mow and Chloe were two dogs I fostered after I worked with Benny. Both dogs came from a rescue who reported the puppies needed trained to no longer bite their staff when the staff tried to take the puppies out of their crate for potential adopters to meet. I understood this rescue took on puppies for rehoming right after weaning. I don’t know if any efforts were made with the young dogs to build habituation skills, the lack of which can create fear issues. I’ve worked with other dogs who developed biting habits from handling errors, and wondered if these young dogs were being taken out of a crate too quickly, and immediately put into a strangers arms which can overwhelm an under-socialized puppy. If the dog remained frightened by this activity, and this frightening activity was repeated again and again, the repetitions of that fearful event can lead to fear biting.
The foster dropped off two crated dogs housed for me to resolve their fear biting. Chloe was a female tan colored mix, and Mow, a male black shepherd mix. I set the crates side-by side with just enough distance for me to sit between the crate. Nearby was a door that lead to an outside pen to allow the dogs to go outside for potty breaks without me needing to physically take them out of the crate.
I gave the puppies a day to settle into my home before working to touch the dogs or remove them from their crates. I did approach the crate to offer treats in between feedings. Cloe was accepting of being fed treats and began to move towards me when I approached. Mow moved to the other side of the crate pushing against the far side. He would not take any treat I held through the crate bars. I did drop the treat for him to eat later.
Chloe readily learned to relax with me after I began my desensitization work with her. I got her used to me reaching into the crate and learning to relax. That was followed by a soothing touch technique, and finally lifting her out. I’d set her in my lap and work to calm her by using more of the soothing touch. I was introduced to the soothing touch in an article that told how a veterinarian named Dr. Linfoot. He could calm an untamed horse in less than an hour. Dr. Linfoot told how he used touch he described as a soothing touch to accomplish his goal. I adapted this technique when working with insecure and fearful dogs and found it worked well.
Mow was still very determined to stay pushed against the far side of the crate, I hoped that him watching me work Chloe would help him learn to relax. It did help a little and Mow began to sit on the far side of the crate and watch me rather than push against the side of the crate. He still refused any treats I offered.
At the end of that week, the rescue called to arrange a pick-up of the two dogs. I explained the dogs needed more training time. The rescue insisted they needed to work on placing them as soon as possible. I negotiated for one more week for Chloe, and planned to wait until after she was gone to negotiate for more time with Mow. I focused all my work with Chloe that next week, except for offering treats to Mow in his crate.
With Chloe gone, I turned my efforts to Mow. I decided to try using calming signals to see if that helped Mow feel more comfortable about my approaching his crate since he still retreated to the other side when I got close. I choose to use the wide mouthed yawn. However, I decided not to use an arc approach. He was used to me walking to Chloe’s crate and sitting next to his crate and was no longer pushing hard against the far side when I approached. I planned on walking calmly toward the crate, with a few pauses to give some calming signals.
With my first calming signal session, I began calmly walking towards Chole’s crate area as if she was still there. Mow watched me like he had before. I stopped my walk at distance far enough away that Mow would not begin his move towards the side of the crate. I then gave Moe my best widemouthed yawn. After that presentation, I stood quietly and gave Mow a moment reflect on my actions, before I turned and walked away. I have found some dogs needs more time than others to process new stimulus, and Mow reminded me of that kind of dog. Another trainer who introduced me to this kind of response called that type dog “reserved.”
Using a similar pattern to what I did with Otis, Mow learned to relax about me approaching the crate. This allowed me to begin my work desensitizing him to me making contact in the crate, so he wouldn’t become so afraid he’d bite. It took more than a couple of weeks before Mow was ready to find his forever home. The rescue allowed me that time if I agreed to place the dog from my residence rather than return him to the adoption facility. Mow began to not only watch me approach, instead of retreat to the back of the cage, he also at times returned my calming signal. I felt the used of calming signals was helpful for reshaping Mow apprehension of people and going onto find his ideal home.



My book "Rescue Your Dog from Fear" was written with both fearful rescue issues and mill dog rescue issues in mind. The book covers detail use of the soothing touch. In addition to this book I did a class through e-trainingfordogs.com on working with mill dog rescues which includes some of the work with Otis, Albert, and the German Shepherd. The accredited class is called Lesson in Fear and Aggression Part 3 - Advanced Desensitization Techniques. This class can be found at https://e-trainingfordogs.com/dog-behavior-training-for-owners/.
ReplyDelete