Part One - Using Calming Signals to Resolve Dog Behavior Issues


Calming signals were introduced to the world in the book “On Talking Terms with Dogs, Calming Signal,” by Turid Rugaas in 1997. For many people this book was a valuable tool when working to learn what dogs are trying to communicate to each other, and even to the dog handler. But, what if calming signals could be used to train a dog? This article, which is presented in three parts, answers that question. Part One covers my introduction to calming signals even before I read the book. I saw a dog trainer who began her training by used calming signals, then put the calming on a cue. I watched as her Boston Terrier went from overly stressed to calm in moments. Part one also tells about my efforts to use calming signals to calm dogs. Part Two, which includes a video, tells about a breakthrough I had when using calming signals on a mill dog rescue who had a reputation of biting people he just met. I also share my success using calming signals with other fearful dogs. Part Three is an interview with Turid Rugaas. 

 

Part One

 

My First Introduction to Calming Signals: Kelly and Hoosier

On the day Kelly introduced me to calming signals, we were waiting our turn to run an agility course; Kelly with Hoosier her Boston Terrier, and me with Cookie my Jack Russell terrier. We chatted as Kelly waited for her ring call. When that call came, Kelly began leading her dog to enter the competition area. But Hoosier suddenly stopped and began to gasp for breath in what some people call a reverse sneeze. This kind of situation isn’t uncommon for Boston’s who are brachycephalic. 

 

I hardly had time to think about how there was no way Kelly was going to make her run, when Kelly stepped in front of Hoosier, relaxed her shoulders and said, “Hoosier, get it together.” Hoosier’s breathing distress subsided and Kelly made a successful run placing in the ribbons. 

 

Sidebar: Brachycephalic is a term that comes from the Greek words Brachy meaning short, and cephalic which refers to the head. Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS) in dogs results from several possible respiratory tract issues, which can include a total collapse of the dog’s airway. The cause of this issue in dogs is the practice of breeding for extremely short noses for aesthetic reasons. Boston Terriers are one breed in a list of dogs who have BOAS issues due to short-nose breeding practices. 

 

I interviewed Kelly about what had gone on with Hoosier. Kelly explained that Hoosier triggered into breathing issues when he became overly excited or stressed, an event she first experience when he was at home. Kelly had recently read the book on calming signals, and decided to see if she could help calm the dog using those signals. Kelly explained that some of the calming signals she used were the head turn, turning her back on the dog, and a yawn. She found that the widemouthed yawn had worked well to help take Hoosier from a stressed situation that could trigger a BOAS episode, to relaxing. Once Hoosier learned to reliably calm with the yawn, Kelly began to add cues for calming including her body posture and the words “Get it together.” 

 

What I had observed at the dog show was the result of a combination of training. Kelly had already trained the dog to sit and focus on her, which Hoosier learned to do even when stressed. With Hoosier’s attention, Kelly then began using different calming signals she read about in Turrid’s book and found that Hoosier calmed the most effectively with the widemouthed yawn. Once Hoosier learned to reliably calm with the use of the widemouthed yawn, Kelly began to add her body language and verbal cue allowing her to calm Hoosier without needed to do the yawn.  

 

Kelly’s process for training was very familiar to me except for the use of a calming signal to try and communicate non-verbally to the dog. However, I’d seen dogs yawn before either when the dog was showing displacement behaviors or appeasement behaviors.

 

Displacement behaviors, as describe in an article in the Whole Dog Journal by Kate Basedow is “when your dog does something normal, but at a weird time that feels out of context. This occurs when your dog is experiencing conflict or frustration.” With yawns associated with displacement behaviors, I had noted that the dog appeared stressed or anxious while yawning. 

 

Yawn are also at times used by dogs displaying appeasement behaviors. Appeasement behaviors are often used by a dog when the dog is are encountering another dog or individual displaying dominance behaviors, or in other ways perceived as a threat. Besides using a yawn, submissive peeing and dogs dropping to the ground and displaying their belly are some of the other ways dogs show appeasement behaviors.  

 


Many people mistake a dog dropping to the ground and displaying a belly as the dog submitting to the owner, when the owner is working to use dominance to change unwanted behaviors. The dog in the picture learned to display appeasement behaviors where her owner worked to use dominance and punishment to stop the dog from killing chickens. That created a habit in the dog to drop on the ground anytime someone directly approached the dog. The dog, who was anticipating adversity, immediately offered an appeasement behavior in hopes of not getting disciplined. This behavior happened even when the dog had done nothing wrong. What the owner didn’t understand was that the appeasement behavior in the dog was not an indication of yielding to the owner’s will when the owner is acting dominant, or using punishment. Dog’s displaying appeasement behaviors like yawns, submissive peeing, or displaying their belly are not thinking about what made their owner hostile, the dog is trying to avoid adversity.

 

 

Yawns from Kelly and Hoosier

Yawns used as calming signals do not have the same intention of displacement or appeasement behaviors. Although appeasement behaviors has a hope of a person calming down as does a calming signal yawn, the calming signal yawn is not done by a dog in an anxious state of mind.  When I watched the photo shoot of Kelly with Hoosier for an article I wrote, I had a chance to see how the two of them interacted when Kelly used yawns as calming signals. I was able to note how Hoosier watched Kelly when she displayed the yawn. Hoosier sat with a relaxed posture as he watched her give her yawn. There were no quick glances towards Kelly from Hoosier because he was too stressed to sustain eye contact, which I’d seen in dogs displaying appeasement or displacement behavior. Although Hoosier responded with a yawn back to Kelly, Hoosier didn’t fidget or cower, but instead remained relaxed, even after the yawn was done. 

 

These two pictures were provided by Ken Gee Photography at https://kengeephoto.photoreflect.com/

 

  

 

Picture 1: Hoosier calmly makes eye contact as Kelly is yawning. 

Picture 2 Hoosier is secure and calm when he returns a yawn.   

 

My Turn to Use Calming Signals

Kelly used calming signals as her initial way of calming a Boston Terrier, then put that response on cue. Having seen Hoosiers response to Kelly’s training when the dog was very stressed, left me wanting to learn more about calming signals. I bought Turids book. The book opened with an illustration of how the author’s dog, an Elkhound named Vesla, was able to thwart an aggressive attack by a Briard using calming signals, and goes onto give illustrations on how dogs use calming signals to communicate to each other in their efforts to address other dogs who are aggressive, afraid, stressed, or just being a nuisance. 

 

Between Turid’s illustration on how well dogs communicated using calming signals, and seeing the results Kelly had worked out, I was excited about using this as a tool. However, Turid’s book only discussed how dogs used calming signals on each other. At that time, I found no other information on people working to use calming signals to change a dogs behavior like Kelly had. Still, I wanted to give calming signals a try to see if they were a viable tool for my dog training business.  

 

My First Attempt Using Calming Signals: Abby’s Fence Racing

Abby was with a three-year-old dog whom I adopted after Cookie was gone. Abby had the habit of racing back and forth along the fence when I came to release her from my outside pen. I decided to try calming signals to see if they would help change her running the fence in response to my approach. 

 

When Abby saw me approaching she’d begin her racing along the fence. I stopped, assumed a secure posture, meaning no slumping, and relaxed my shoulders. Then, I did a head turn like Vesla did to calm the Briard. Abby didn’t react to the calming signal. 

 

I quickly realized the problem. When Abby raced the fence, she became distracted by the intrinsic activity of running back and forth. Her participation in this self-rewarding behavior resulted in the calming signals going unnoticed. To get the calming signal to work, I needed to get Abby’s attention. I first tried standing still and not responding to Abby racing the fence to see if she would change that behavior. This took some time, but Abby finally slowed down enough to glance my way. Once she gave me a look, I offered her a calming signal. I repeated the head-turn calming signal each time she looked my way. When Abby finally stopped, I marked that action with praise. However, it took many more repetitions of offering calming signals, and marking the desired behavior to change Abby’s over excited behavior of racing the fence to more calmly watching me approach. 

 

My first attempt using calming signals was a little disappointing. I had no idea how time consuming Kelly’s training was with Hoosier to teach him to calm using yawns, but for me, especially after reading about how Turid’s dog stopped an attack so quickly, I expected this tool to work quicker than it did. Still, the remarkable way Hoosier calmed that day urged me to again try using calming signals in my training. The next time I decided to use calming signals for training was with mill dog rescues. 

 

Working with Mill Dog Rescues

From time to time, I take on fosters to resolve the behavior issues that are preventing the dog from finding a forever home. After attending a lecture at my local humane society given by the founder of the NMDR (National Mill Dog Rescue), I learned that mill dogs are a term for dog housed at commercial breeding facilities in the United States. These facilities are considered to have low baseline care standards which often results in inhumane commercial breeding. 

 

NMDR kennels had experienced volunteers and fosters who routinely worked to begin the process resolving some of the behaviors associated with mill dog rescues, so these dogs can have a successful adoption. I decided to go to the NMDR adoption kennels and shadow some of the experience people who worked with these dogs in hopes of expanding my education. There I met two dogs whose fear biting issues were too problematic for the volunteer trainers, or for the regular mill dog fosters to manage. I had a lot of experience working dogs though fear aggression issues and felt I could help these two dogs, so I agreed to foster them. 

 

Otis (a poodle) and Albert (a Chihuahua)

The two dogs I agreed to foster were three years old, which is much younger than the normal mill dog surrender ages of six to seven years, a time when the dog’s breeding ability wanes. Both dogs were surrendered at this early age due to biting issues. Although most mill dog rescues are readily placed in fosters and/or new homes. Otis and Albert had lived at NMDR for a year. 

 

When Otis and Albert arrived at my home, I put them in a very large crate (something they were accustom to) and planned on giving them about a week to acclimate to their first time in a house before working to touch them or try and pick them up. In the mornings I’d clean their litter box, and attend to the food and water. My working to clean the cage was stressful for the dogs. When I approached the cage, Albert showed uncertainty and would move to the far side of the cage. Otis not only retreated to the back of the cage, he soon began to take on a posture where he shut his eyes, rounded his shoulders and lowered head. His breathing was slow and he maintained this state for the entire time I was in the room. Otis began to repeat this kind of action each time I came into the room and approached his crate. The state looked so much like he was in a deep and prolonged prayer session I decided to call it “The Mill Dog Prayer” especially after I saw other mill dogs respond this way when the dog felt trapped or helpless. Before I left the cage, I’d always leave a couple of high-value treats near each dog. 

 

 

  

 

Albert also sometimes did the Mill Dog Prayer, a name I used to describe body position I have observed in mill dogs when they feel completely overwhelmed or helpless. They assume this position rather than engage in fighting or fleeing.

 

After the first week, Albert seemed less tense about me coming up to the cage, and was willing to take a treat from my hand when I opened the cage and presented it to him. Otis was more committed to taking on his mill dog prayer pose. 

 

In my psychology courses in college, I was first introduced to “learned helplessness.” In dogs, this is described as a condition which results after a dog endures repeated, inescapable stress or punishment, which makes the dog believe their actions do not matter. This can result in the dog completely shutting down. Otis’ mill dog prayer response when I came to his cage made me suspect he was suffering from learned helplessness. 

 

To help a dog get out of a learned helplessness situation, the interactions with the dogs need to not have any aversive pressures. Using positive reinforcement, and allowing a dog to make a choice which leads to a good outcome can help. Unfortunately, I couldn’t use treats with Otis because he’d shut down before I got to him and wouldn’t eat while I was in the room. What I needed was a way to calm and reassure this dog at a distance. I felt using calming signals may help. 

 

When working to use calming signals, I watched Otis as I approached. The pattern I observed was Otis tensed when I began walking towards his cage. As I got closer, his gaze became less focused. By the time I was half way to his to his cage, he’d go into his mill dog prayer. 

 

I began my calming signals training about three hours after morning chores. In preparation for using a calming signal, when I entered the room, I watching him closely, and noted how he was watching me. When I was three quarters of the way to his cage, before his gaze became glazed over, I stopped. A moment later, I presented Otis the head turn calming signal. I held the calming signal a few moments, then returned my head forward without looking directly at Otis. A moment later, I calmly turn and walk out of the room.  

 

The next training session was in the afternoon. I worked to repeat everything exactly the way I’d done it the first time. However, I noticed that Otis’ reaction was different than the first session. I do a lot of desensitization work using distance. I often use an approach and retreat method. With the approach and retreat, dogs often watch my body as I approach. With Otis’ second session, he looked towards my head. I did my calming signal then left. 

 

The next morning I approached the cage like I I normally did, and accepted the fact that Otis would respond to my cleaning the cage with a mill dog prayer. A couple of hours later, I returned to repeat my calming signal. Otis attentively watched me as I approached the same area where I stopped the day before to do the calming signal. I repeated the lesson the same as I had the day before. However, in the afternoon when I returned for another calming signal, since Otis was watching me, but not showing tension, I took a few steps closer to the cage before I did my calming signal routine. That began a process of incrementally stepping closer to the cage with my calming signals sessions, and adding a third repetition during the day.  By the end of a week, I made it all the way to the cage without Otis shutting down. 

 

 

  

 

It took a several head turns and managing distance before Otis stopped doing a mill dog prayer when I approached his crate. 

 

Both Otis and Albert had a lot of issues to work them through, including that they were terrified of being touched, needed house trained, and a general fear of everything in the world outside of my house. When it came to resolution of biting issues, Albert’s responded well to desensitization and helping him learn habituation skills. 

 

  

 

Otis learned to relax with me coming to his cage, but his fear of being touched still needed addressed. I didn’t use calming signals for that issues. Instead I’d approach calmly, slowly reach out and touch him, and keep my hand in the initial place of contact until he relaxed at least a little. Rather than pick him up, I attached a leash to his harness, to take him back inside to his crate. 

 

Otis’ biting issues had a different pattern then I’d seen in other dogs, he would unexpectedly go into what I described as a biting frenzy. When in his “frenzy” state, he didn’t have a specific target when biting, but would grab at a lot of things within reach, and bite in rapid session. The entire time he was in this state, he was fairly unresponsive to other stimulus such as sounds, and the use of a leash to contain his biting at anything his teeth could reach. 

 

When he came out of the biting episode, Otis seemed disoriented for a few moments. I choose not to interact with him. Instead I allowed him time to completely recover from the episode. After he recovered, he showed no after effects of what had just happened. He didn’t cower, react to movement around him, or noises. 

 


          

 

This picture shows one of Otis’ biting episodes which I didn’t find a specific trigger. When he began to bite mindlessly, he was snapping at nothing until the leash got close enough for him to grab. At that point he stayed focused on biting that object.

 

Approach, Approach, Approach

One of Otis’ biting frenzies where I could identify the trigger, was one I caused by using the wrong approach. On that day, I was running late for leaving for an appointment. Still I wanted to put the mill dogs in the outside pen where they could enjoy the nice day. I’d already taken Albert out. While carrying Otis through the living room, I suddenly remembered something I needed to take with me. I asked my husband to hold Otis a moment while I grabbed what I needed. After I set the item on the kitchen table, I went towards my husband to grab Otis, breaking all of the rules for approaching a fearful dog. I walked straight towards the dog, looking directly at the dog, and approached with intentional steps. 

 

Although Otis was sitting calmly on my husband’s lap prior to my approach, Otis immediately went into one of his biting frenzies. Before my husband could push Otis out of his lap, my husband sustained five bites including one puncture wound. I still regret that mistake. I also realized from that incident that to feel Otis was over his biting for good, I needed to do lot of proofing with the the dog. I did accomplish that task and Otis found his forever home. 

 

 

  

 

A lot of my work was more than working to resolve biting issues in Otis and Albert, I also worked to better habituate the dogs to the world around them and to house train them. Otis not only bonded with strongly with his new caretaker, he became very social toward people he didn’t know, allowing him to accompany his owner to the beauty shop, the tennis court, and almost everywhere she went.

 

 

Sometime after Otis found his forever home, I found a new way to approach fearful dogs to add to my knowledge base. Ironically, this method of approach is mentioned in the book on calming signals. However, I didn’t understand the importance of that approach and exactly how to use it, until I worked with a mill dog rescue named Benny. 

 

Comments

  1. Author note: The books referenced in this article are "On Talking Terms with Dogs: Calming Signals" by Turid Rugaas, both the original version and her revised books. I also more recently reviewed her DVD-Calming Signals: What Your Dog Tells You, after my work with Benny.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Part Two - Lessons from Benny, a Fear Aggressive Mill Dog Rescue

Part Three-Turid Rugaas Interview About Calming Signals I’d Seen in Mill Dog Res